UK dysfunction: What’s Elon Musk’s recreation?

X can generally really feel like two parallel universes.

There’s a model of selecting a platform to announce that the President of the USA is not going to run for re-election. A world authority on a specific topic will use X to current rising occasions to their consultants.

Then false claims, hate and conspiracy theories, together with many posts about latest riots and protests throughout the UK, are really useful to tens of millions who’ve made no effort to hunt them out.

On the middle of all of it is X's proprietor, Elon Musk, one of many world's richest males. However this isn’t only a story about monetization technique and the strategies X used throughout his tenure and the way they improve divisive content material.

There may be additionally a rising narrative about how Mr Musk chooses to remark overtly on the unrest within the UK.

And nobody is certain what his recreation plan is.

Mr Musk purchased what was then referred to as Twitter in 2022. In November 2023, the location reinstated the account of beforehand banned far-right activist and convicted felon Stephen Yaxley-Lennon.

This week, Mr Musk responded to Yaxley-Lennon's put up with two exclamation marks – in different phrases, stirring the pot.

Yaxley-Lennon took purpose at UK Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer for his remarks after riots broke out in Southport following the killing of three ladies. The Prime Minister accused Yaxley-Lennon of branding anybody upset by the killings as “thugs”. Mr Starmer's speech particularly referred to thugs as these throwing bricks at law enforcement officials.

Yaxley-Lennon additionally criticized the Prime Minister's feedback about growing police powers in response to the riots.

Mr Musk later urged that “civil conflict is inevitable” in response to a video of the riots. A spokesman for the Prime Minister stated there was “no justification” for the declare.

Mr Musk doubled down once more – responding to the Prime Minister's put up about assaults on Muslim communities: “Aren't you anxious about assaults on all communities?” Mr Musk repeated the sentiment in his personal tweet, leveling allegations of anti-racism and violence from Muslim protesters and accusing the police of a “one-sided” strategy.

Not if X didn't have already got loads of content material round occasions in Southport earlier than Mr Musk's interventions.

False claims Muslim refugee chargeable for Southport murders arrives in UK by boat in 2023 X unfold like wildfire. They then unfold to different social media platforms and had been even posted on some Telegram channels – however essentially the most frenetic, amplified dialog was occurring on X.

The pretend information accounts, which have a observe file of selling unsubstantiated conspiracy theories about every little thing from pandemics and vaccines to wars, are profiled — after which shared by distinguished political commentators, politicians and influencers.

Profiles that reached essentially the most customers with these concepts usually purchased blue ticks, which means their posts got extra prominence on the platform.

Mr Musk, along with his personal blue tick and 193 million followers, shares content material with some profiles and, in doing so, amplifies their message.

There may be presently no definitive reply to what motivates Mr Musk.

His presence as an energetic participant on his personal platform actually makes X the speak of the city.

For all of the furor surrounding his possession of X, final month the location had 251 million international each day energetic customers within the second quarter of this yr, up 1.6% from the identical interval a yr earlier. After all, this may be attributed to many elements – like what's occurring on this planet. Whereas these figures signify a drop in progress, X continues to be a focus for digital conversations.

For all of the warnings that X shall be discontinued underneath Elon Musk, all kinds of customers proceed to put up — together with many world leaders and distinguished political figures of all stripes.

It might even have one thing to do with Mr Musk's views on regulatory threats – notably within the UK, the web safety legislation enacted underneath the earlier authorities.

When it comes into full drive in 2025, it is going to require social media firms to take away unlawful content material, together with “racially or religiously aggravated” content material. Mr Musk has repeatedly voiced his considerations that efforts by governments to control social media platforms – resembling his personal – threat infringing on free speech.

Others surprise if Sander van der Linden, a professor of social psychology on the College of Cambridge, spent an excessive amount of time on X. really useful Mr Musk is “self-aggrandizing on his personal platform”.

After all, the causes of the protests and riots within the UK clearly lengthen past social media.

That is additionally why the previous Twitter, the pre-Musk model, wasn't excellent.

Its moderation insurance policies have led to accusations of bias and referrals, limiting freedom of expression to sure classes of accounts. Trolls additionally flocked to this. However on paper, its insurance policies and strategy are totally different — and, from analyzing my very own feed earlier than and after the takeover, it was is totally different.

Instantly after the acquisition, Mr Musk emphasised the significance of honesty to all events – together with what was shared on Twitter on the time. He has made it clear that freedom of expression is a central precedence at X – and as a personal citizen, he has the suitable to share his opinion on political or different subjects, similar to another person.

A newer growth is Mr Musk's clear resolution to help particular political positions and candidates.

For instance, she shares content material important of her help of Donald Trump after an assassination try, or of Trump's opponent Kamala Harris. He shared some posts that had been very hostile to some liberal views.

Now he has additionally determined to touch upon some vital problems with British life.

Evolution is a posh dynamic. As proprietor, Elon Musk oversees the choices made by X that decide which content material is allowed and actively really useful to customers. On the similar time, his account is taken into account essentially the most adopted on this planet and he has performed a major function in shaping the tone of X's extremely publicized and controversial content material.

I’ve reached out to the social media firm a number of occasions relating to the riots within the UK, together with a number of interview requests for Mr Musk. I even requested him on X and posted. He didn’t reply to any of my interview requests.

Mr Musk has voiced his concern that the media is now not held to account. And but more often than not, once I wish to ask inquiries to each him and X – there is no such thing as a response from the social media large. In its publicly out there tips, X continues to share that defending and defending the person's voice is its prime precedence.

So as a substitute, I needed to think about and remedy what I might say to him if he lastly agreed to speak.

One of many first issues I ask is: “What's your recreation plan?”

A query solely he can reply.

BBC Indepth The brand new house on the web site and app for the most effective evaluation and experience from our prime journalists. Underneath a novel new model, we'll convey you recent views that problem assumptions and in-depth reporting on the most important points that assist make sense of a posh world. And we'll be that includes thought-provoking content material throughout BBC Sounds and iPlayer. We're beginning small however pondering huge, and we wish to know what you assume – ship us your suggestions by clicking the button beneath.